Defining ‘Withdrawal’ From Afghanistan

Posted on by

COMMON DREAMS– Barack Obama’s June 22 announcement of a phased troop withdrawal from Afghanistan was often portrayed as a major step towards ending the war, with many outlets neglecting to accurately explain the pace of escalation that has happened under his watch.

When Obama took office in 2009, the U.S. had about 34,000 troops in Afghanistan. Obama has initiated two major troop increases in Afghanistan: about 20,000 additional troops were announced in February 2009, followed by the December 2009 announcement that an another 33,000 would be deployed as well; other smaller increases have brought the total to 100,000. Much of the media conversation portrays the announced withdrawal schedule as a removal of all the surge troops–“the withdrawal of the entire surge force by the end of next summer,” as the New York Times put it (6/23/11)–which ignores the initial escalation.

News accounts over how many troops might leave should account for the total U.S. military presence in Afghanistan, in historical context. As ThinkProgress noted (6/22/11), if the reductions are carried out as planned, the United States would still have far more troops in Afghanistan than it did when Obama came into office and more than at any point during former president George W. Bush’s administration. This means that the troop reduction would not put us much closer to actually ending the war by the end of 2012.

That was not the impression many in the media were giving; coverage often made it sound as if the war was ending. “Obama Moves Toward Exit from Afghanistan” read one Reuters headline (6/22/11). USA Today reported (6/23/11), “President Obama heralded the beginning of the end of the nation’s 10-year war in Afghanistan on Wednesday.”

Reporting also nearly universally excluded any mention of the 100,000 Pentagon contractors currently in Afghanistan, which double the U.S. military commitment there. Given the full context, it’s hard to read a phased pullout of 30,000 out of 200,000 over the course of an entire year as a “rapid” withdrawal (Los Angeles Times, 6/23/11). Nor is it clear how this withdrawal, which conforms to Obama’s promise to begin to pull out troops from the second surge within 18 months of their deployment, merits a headline like the New York Times‘ “Obama Will Speed Military Pullout From Afghan War” (6/23/11).

Instead, the pace of the withdrawal, and the remaining U.S. presence in the country, reveal that the Afghan War is a long way from being over. A Washington Post headline before the speech (6/22/11) was: “Obama’s Challenge: Leaving, But Not Too Quickly.” Given the public’s anti war sentiment, the real challenge might be exactly the opposite: leaving too slowly.


FAIR, the national media watch group, has been offering well-documented criticism of media bias and censorship since 1986. We work to invigorate the First Amendment by advocating for greater diversity in the press and by scrutinizing media practices that marginalize public interest, minority and dissenting viewpoints.

Amy Goodman on Democracy Now explains how President Obama’s Afghan drawdown will leave the US occupation at his pre-surge levels.


Leave a Reply


  • Media Roots Radio: Schrödinger’s Super Patriot – The 2001 Anthrax Mystery Part 1
  • Media Roots Radio: 12 Russians Indicted, Helsinki Putin Panic, Trump’s Reversal
  • acTVism Munich: Interview with Abby Martin – Corporate Media, Imperialism & People Power
  • Media Roots Radio: Interview with Anoa Changa on Progressive Black Activists Targeted in New McCarthyism

  • Empire Files Podcast: An Autopsy on Liberal Feminism & American Islamophobia
  • Abby Martin Confronts Nancy Pelosi Over Pentagon Spending at COP26
  • Empire Files Podcast: How The Pentagon Runs Hollywood
  • Media Roots Radio: Neocon Tentacles into Populism, the Hudson Institute, the Doomsday Machine & Kahn !!!
  • Empire Files: Iraq Vet Disrupts George W. Bush Speech, Sept. 19 2021
  • Empire Files: Never Forget: Lessons of the Post-9/11 Warpath
  • Empire Files: Afghanistan War Pays Off BIG For Generals Who Lied
  • Media Roots Radio: Time to End the War on Terrorism & Panic Over a Multipolar World w/ Scott Horton
  • Media Roots Radio: China Derangement Syndrome, Big Pharma Opioid Erasure & Apple Fed Pedo Hunters
  • CIA Stories: The Cuban Who Conned the CIA
  • Empire Files Podcast: SOS Cuba: An Extensive Web of CIA Plots & Propaganda
  • Empire Files Podcast: BDS Victories On The Rise | feat. leaders of Block The Boat
  • Media Roots Radio: COG Measures & the War on Terrorism Horseshoe w/ Whitney Webb
  • Media Roots Radio: Cure For Havana Syndrome & Info War Against Cuba w/ Alan MacLeod
  • Empire Files Podcast: Disturbing Truth About Israel’s New Government w/ Miko Peled & Abby Martin