The Thin Blue Line: The First Time a Cop Lied To Me

Posted on by

MEDIA ROOTS – This article by David Noriega, published on TheNewInquiry, vividly diagrams the pressures inherent on a young college graduate when he goes to work for the NYC Civilian Complaint Review Board, wherein he investigates citizens’ complaints against NYPD officers. Where other areas that have the means use attorneys for the important task of holding peace officers accountable to citizens, the overextended CCRB provided steady employment for recent grads like Mr. Noriega, as long as they could accomplish the task of minimizing paperwork and consequences for the NYPD.

Younger, more inexperienced workers were more likely to follow orders and be amenable to a culture that valued exoneration of officers, discounting citizen grievances, and not taking a stand on controversial issues like stop-and-frisk. The author expresses some guarded hope, and lists some recent, albeit limited, improvements to the CCRB’s function. This cautionary tale will give you a glimpse of what it feels like to be on the inside of a powerless bureaucratic machine whose ostensible task is keeping the NYPD from abusing its authority. 

Laurie Kirchner for Media Roots


THENEWINQUIRY – I will always remember the first time a cop lied to me. Or rather, the first time that I knew beyond a doubt that a cop was lying to me, sitting right there in the interview room with a tape recorder in front of him.

It was early in my tenure as an investigator at the New York City Civilian Complaint Review Board, the city agency established in 1993 to investigate allegations of misconduct against NYPD officers. The case was a fairly straightforward stop-and-frisk incident near the massive New York City Housing Authority complexes along Avenue D in Manhattan. The complainant, a man in his early 20s, alleged that a plainclothes cop had stopped, frisked, and searched him after he stepped out of a bodega. He’d given a guy a cigarette, and before he knew it, the cop came up from behind him, grabbed him by the coat, and after a quick scuffle, pushed him against a wall.

I’d already interviewed the cop’s unusually forthcoming partner, whose testimony matched the complainant’s. That’s how I knew the cop was making stuff up. Lots of stuff.

Continue reading The Thin Blue Line


photo by Jean-Edouard BABIN under creative commons

Leave a Reply


  • Government Agents Gone Rogue, Iran Letter & House of Cards Propaganda
  • MLK Jr. – The Uncomfortable Truths History Books Won’t Touch
  • The Official Rwanda Story Unravels
  • ‘The 2001 Anthrax Deception’ Interview with Graeme MacQueen

  • Who Is To Blame For The Refugee Crisis?
  • A Very Heavy Agenda, Documentary Film
  • Baltimore Uprising, Freddie Gray & the Police State
  • Saudi Arabia’s Yemen War, Factory of Terror & American Bribery
  • Washington, DC: The Emperor Wears No Clothes
  • Cyber Warfare, Surveillance & US Government’s Dick Pic Collection
  • Panopticon Fatigue – Life, Sex and Death under the East German Stasi
  • CIA Torture Whistleblower: Wake Up America, You’re Next
  • Internationally Banned Tear Gas: For Domestic Use Only
  • Clinton 2016: Endless War Guaranteed
  • ‘The 2001 Anthrax Deception’ Interview with Graeme MacQueen
  • Drone Wars Can’t Exist Without Decades-Long Genocide in Congo
  • Prisoner Abuse: Indefinite Detention in Mississippi & Collective Punishment in North Carolina
  • Media Roots Radio – The 9/11 Bulletin, Interview with Jon Gold
  • What If Edward Snowden Leaked All the Documents?