American Jews Who Reject Zionism Say Events Aid Cause

Posted on by

NY TIMES– One day nearly 20 years ago, Stephen Naman was preparing to help the rabbi of his Reform Jewish temple in South Carolina move the congregation into a new building. Mr. Naman had just one request: Could the rabbi stop placing the flag of Israel on the altar?

“We don’t go to synagogue to pray to a flag,” Mr. Naman, 63, recalled having said in a recent telephone interview.

That rabbi acceded to the request. So, after being transferred to North Carolina and joining a temple there six or seven years later, Mr. Naman asked its rabbi to remove the Israeli flag. This time, the reaction was more predictable.

“The rabbi said that would be terrible,” recounted Mr. Naman, a retired paper company executive who now lives outside Jacksonville, Fla., “and that he’d be embarrassed to be rabbi of such a congregation.” As shocking as Mr. Naman’s insistence on taking Israel out of Judaism may seem, it actually adheres to a consistent strain within Jewish debate. Whether one calls it anti-Zionism or non-Zionism — and all these terms are contested and loaded — the effort to separate the Jewish state from Jewish identity has centuries-old roots.

For the past 68 years, that stance has been the official platform of the group Mr. Naman serves as president of, the American Council for Judaism. And while the establishment of Israel and its centrality to American Jews consigned the council to irrelevancy for decades, the intense criticism of Israel now growing among a number of American Jews has made Mr. Naman’s group look significant, or even prophetic.

It is not that members are flocking to the council. The group’s mailing list is only in the low thousands, and its Web site received a modest 10,000 unique visitors in the last year. Its budget is a mere $55,000. As Mr. Naman acknowledges, the council’s history of opposition to Zionism renders it “radioactive” for even liberal American Jewish groups, like J Street and Peace Now.

Yet the arguments that the council has consistently levied against Zionism and Israel have shot back into prominence over the last decade, with the collapse of the Oslo peace process, Israel’s wars in Lebanon and Gaza, and most recently the fatal attack on a flotilla seeking to breach the naval blockade of the Hamas regime. One need not agree with any of the council’s positions to admit that, for a certain faction of American Jews, they have come back into style.

Read full article about American Jews who Reject Zionism.

© COPYRIGHT NY TIMES, 2010

Photo by flickr user RonAlmog

Leave a Reply

RELATED NEWS

  • The Philippines Trafficking Epidemic: Past & Present
  • Buying a Slave – The Hidden World of US/Philippines Trafficking
  • The Hidden Purging of Millions of Voters
  • The Sikh Experience in America
  • WORLD NEWS

  • Empire Files Podcast: A Russian Anti-War Perspective on Ukraine
  • Media Roots Radio: Hollywood Gets Tough On Putin, Ukraine Scorched Earth Info War, Banning Russia
  • Media Roots Radio: RIP RT America, The End of An Era
  • Media Roots Radio: Revenge of the Kagans, DOD’s 11 Ukrainian Bio Labs, 60 Mins Targeted Individuals, Havana Reviews
  • Media Roots Radio: Fog of Cold War, Sitting Duck Op, Doomsday Clock 100 Seconds to Midnight
  • Abby Martin Confronts Nancy Pelosi Over Pentagon Spending at COP26
  • Media Roots Radio: Cure For Havana Syndrome & Info War Against Cuba w/ Alan MacLeod
  • Empire Files Podcast: Colombia On Fire w/ Student Leader From Protest Epicenter
  • Empire Files: Debunking Israel’s ‘Human Shield’ Defense in Gaza Massacre
  • Media Roots Radio: Gaza Under Attack Again, Operation Prison Wall Guardian & Alt-Media Zionism
  • Empire Files Podcast: #SaveSheikhJarrah: The Fight for East Jerusalem
  • Media Roots Radio: Mother of All Afghanistan Podcasts, Sex Cults & Cop Trials
  • Empire Update w/ Abby Martin: Arctic War, Aid to Israel Challenge, Army VR Money Pit
  • Empire Files: US Retreats From Afghanistan: Truth Behind The Empire’s Defeat
  • Empire Files: Uganda Dictatorship: Imperialism’s Pearl of Africa